2020 Census: No Citizenship Question


The Constitution provides that, “Representatives shall be apportioned among the Several states according to their respective numbers, counting the whole number of persons in each state.” So starts the 277 page ruling by Judge Jesse Furman opposing the Trump government’s decision to include the citizenship question in the 2020 US Census. Billions of federal dollars are apportioned based on census numbers.

The Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross’s decision to try and include the citizenship question has been opposed by the very body that advises the Bureau – the Census Scientific Advisory Committee composed of economists, demographers and researchers. The Commerce Secretary went against the Committee’s recommendations to issue his proposal. The Judge declared that Secretary Ross’s decision was “arbitrary and capricious.”

How will this affect Indian-Americans? Just one example given below.

In 2017, among those securing the legal H-1 B visa, 76% of all H-1Bs went to highly skilled tech professionals drawn from India. The average wait time for a green card is around 15 years. Once the green card is processed, they have to wait an additional five years to apply for citizenship. As the years drag on in legal wait times, these individuals directly contribute to the US economy and pay taxes, while using services.

We are not standing up for Indian-Americans alone, but for every minority group that needs to be counted for the 2020 census.

Incorrect representation of any group provides a baseline measure that will lead to disproportionate use of federal, state and local resources. To use the Voting Rights act as the premise for the inclusion of the citizenship question, is a dystopian scene in the making in front of our eyes.

My word as a naturalized US Citizen should have standing – so, too, should the voices of the many that stand behind me.

Our elected officials need to stand true to the document that starts with the words –

We, the people for the stated objective in the document that guides us is the “more perfect union.

Nirupama Vaidhyanathan is the editor of India Currents magazine.

You May Like This

Redistricting Will Reflect The Diverse Face Of America

As U.S. minorities grow to the fifty percent mark, efforts to stifle their voting rights acccelerate. Sara Sadhwani, one of 14 members of the California Citizen

India at the Olympics

This article is a two-part series on India's participation in the previous Olympic games and the upcoming Olympic games.  Like millions of others, I am eagerly

Kala Bagai Way: The First Street In the US Named After a Historic Indian American Woman

When Kalai Bagai first arrived in San Francisco on September 6th, 1915 with her husband Vaishno and three sons, local newspapers flocked to cover the story of t

Sign-up and join our newsletter today!

* indicates required