When the headlines hit that a lewd photograph was sent from Weiner’s account to a young lady who was not his wife, very few people were convinced of his total innocence. It was a known fact that many of the people Weiner followed on Twitter were young women who were not even residents of his congressional district, and at least one was a professional sex worker.
It did not take a congressional investigation or a detective to figure out that Mr. Weiner had a great deal of interest in women other than his wife of less than one year—Huma Abedin, close personal assistant of Hillary Rodham Clinton since the mid-1990s.
Abedin is an American Muslim of South Asian descent—her father, an Iran expert, was born in pre-partition India and her mother, a professor of sociology in Saudi Arabia, was born in Pakistan. She was born in the United States but raised primarily in Saudi Arabia, where her mother still resides, nearly 16 years after Huma’s father passed away.
Beyond the small sphere of her personal friends and family, the public could only wonder why she married Anthony Weiner —a man whose current scandal is not a great leap from the playboy image he held before he married her.
After Weiner’s admission of post-marital philandering. there have been calls for Abdedin to step away from the relationship. “Don’t be another Pakistani Good Wife” one Twitter follower posted after Weiner’s confession (referring the popular TNT series that deals with the fallout of a similar political scandal). Don’t follow your boss’s advice, said countless others, referencing Hillary Clinton’s well-known history of standing by her man even after the fact of his cheating was beyond doubt.
What is interesting in Abedin’s case is that despite a public image that puts her allegiance to the United States and its foreign policy in little doubt—she could, after all, have pursued a political career in any number of other places, given her heritage, linguistic skills, and cultural knowledge—she is still viewed as somehow foreign, even by Americans with a similar heritage.
Though her boss, a white woman, stood by a cheating husband, if Abedin were to do it, it would be the South Asian wife in her —that traditional notion of a woman who will put up with anything because society demands it —that will have compelled her to stay, or so the argument goes.
There is very little discussion about the reasons she is where she is today and the choices she made to get there.
She works for a Secretary of State who has presided over a Pakistan policy that has been anything but beneficial to the people of Pakistan, a Middle East policy that has seen or expanded wars in the predominantly Muslim nations of Iraq, Afghanistan, Pakistan, and now Libya, and a Saudi Arabia policy that continues on the American government tradition of avoiding any discussion, let alone criticism, of the kingdom—most recently failing to address the very serious issues of women’s rights in the region. And she is married to a previously reputed playboy 12 years her senior who, until his resignation, had a very promising career as a possible mayor of New York, or even higher office.
There is very little discussion about how her overall political trajectory and life decisions might play into her staying with this man after he clearly has shown little regard for their marriage.
If she stays, the Hillary parallels would suggest political motivations—but even Hillary’s behavior, after decades of marriage, could have at least partially been chalked up to sentimentality. If Abedin leaves, she would prove that she is human, contrary to Weiner’s famous comment that “there’s some dispute as to whether Huma’s actually human or not”.
She would carry more clout, both with her fellow South-Asian and Muslim Americans, and with her political supporters.
Either way, judging by her past life choices, her heritage would have very little to do with it.
Follow Shirin Sadeghi on Twitter: www.twitter.com/ShirinSadeghi or @ShirinSadeghi